Skip to main content

Missed Encounters of Education of East and West - The Gaps through which the Global Peaks


Hello and Namaste!

Having been on the staff list of our NGO for a long time, I now present the first of a series of articles to be placed on a global, yet so very closed plane of communicative activity: Slumbering in a den of iniquity, literally where one is told not to look, should not look because that would amount to a sense of inappropriateness to the “cultured” self. The question of placement of these publications is important due to the kind of work we pursue: On a greater scale, we are motivated to make education accessible to those, who do not possess the possibility of acquiring it due to a variety of socio-economic factors, placing them at the further end of the receiving chain. This seemingly noble endeavour that everyone can nod their head to opens up a space of issues that can best be formulated in sets of questions. Each article will centre around one of these questions chosen, the first one being: “And after?”.


By today’s global standard, education has acquired a fundamental selection process: At universities, we find the hard science/soft science split, ascribing a certain scientificness that stems from the experimentations with natural laws that then extendedly fall into place as such, to the natural sciences, over the soft sciences’ largely basing themselves in the extensive study of the human condition in the social and cultural sphere, the arts and the humanities.[1] From that selection on, if one is to take it seriously, each and everyone, in an ideal, interconnected condition of human relations is promised the fulfillment of their own path within or without academia. And so it is logical to start early within the education, to supply the interests of the students and have them not find their way but create their own path.

If we now reflect this status quo and conclusion back onto the reality of Indo-European or Indo-Western relations, the image is sobering. We find two almost completely separated trajectories of socio-cultural gravitation. While some cherish their respect and value on the socially networked image of their life, others find dissatisfaction with the coordinates they were given, saw their trajectory in a different direction or got disappointed where they ended up and had to move on from there. For the cases, in which the factor of path creation over finding a way becomes the priority, the question of “And after?”, is one that provokes different modes of answering, not as worth getting into at this point. More importantly, we find that neither side gives more than the other. Either we have the bitter lightness of absolute freedom experienced as a fundamental limitation or even cause to a depression in the spirit of motivation or the provision of actual substantial limitations within the choice-range to every individual. In any case, thinking about a next step is sure to excite a certain amount of anxiety of the new, the unknown.

What needs to be taken note of is where those separated trajectories of socio-cultural gravitation place the individual’s anxiety of the next step: Where in the West, guilt is mostly experienced at the feeling of not enjoying the conditions of study and lifestyle enough, for some particle of enjoyment might not have been caught, for the rural student from India it is more likely to feel guilty at not excelling enough. The expat, no matter where from, essentially experiences the drive to pursuit for which she or he will have to justify themselves in front of where they came from. Expectations cannot be disregarded, neither at the individual, familial nor social level. Somehow, this path has to hold what the pursuit has promised for on the outset. The sole difference between the Western and the Indian expat in this global society, is that the issues both are likely to face, are, to each other, as already described in the title, locked in dens of iniquity. The different lines of “enjoyment” of the move abroad substantially presuppose the sets of issues one is to face: inertia at the sight of a corridor with too many open doors vs. heaviness due to a seemingly insurmountable split between individual capacity and the amalgamation of expectations to excel.

At this point it is important to give advice of caution as much as trust in the capacity to be able to manage, on the condition of an honest pursuit of one’s own Karma. Simple assertions of that “it will be fine” prove too little, whereas stressing urges to excel prove too heavily simplistic. It is important to be aware of one’s own predicament, no matter whether it is in the corridor of open doors or at the face of a mission to be fulfilled. Our task as Motivate India is not only to facilitate possibilities but point towards a direction our students will start to give on their own upon creating their path with the use of our facilities at the start. For us it will be important to give guidance towards creating a multilateral understanding for the student to take up the greatest amount of influence he or she can take in understanding and communicating their path to peers, family and themselves. Only then will the question of “And after?”, find an appropriate answer that can lie within the Karma, the work each of our students puts into their own path, rather than in predications of expectations or inertia.

Finally, this recreates our mission as Motivate India Rural, for the opening of the local level of education, for us, must entail the possibility of opening the world up to our students. Exactly in this next move lies the difficulty of what I call the inappropriateness of issues of the Western to the Indian student and vice versa. Trajectories of Indian expats to work for the trajectory of migration westward essentially displace the student not only without but within. Besides the fact that some of our students will gain the intention to take on the world for what it has to offer to them, this step needs substantial support of transcultural understanding from our side. What is meant by this is the understanding of issues that would seem inappropriate to either centre of social gravity set up by the different socio-cultural (and socio-economic) backgrounds faced when the West and rural India become within reach, connectible and approachable.

So as concerns the question of “And after?”, we want to instill patience as much as calmness, eagerness to work as much as the readiness to let go and understand. Every den of iniquity that will be encountered underway deserves fearlessness and trust to explore, analyse and understand. In the honest pursuit of one’s own Karma, the root we at Motivate India believe in, we will do our best to facilitate that pursuit with the knowledge necessary to create an own. The globalised nature of our world is set to break through to rural India through our kind of work. It would be irresponsible to not consider the impact this will naturally have on students and their families, as we try to supply and encourage braveness and curiosity over heaviness and fear.

Written by:
Nikolai Markov
Content writer, Public Relation Officer in Europe
Bachelors , University of Amsterdam



[1] Of course not to forget the social sciences, oscillating between the two

Comments

  1. bonsoir, l'article évoque le karma. il semble que vous ayez décidé de l'implémenter instantanément. Meilleurs vœux!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Purpose of Motivation India-Rural

                                     If we look around ourselves then we will find that students are losing the zeal to study and to become something in their li ves, especially in the rural area, which is the worst scenario as the majority of Indian population resides in these areas. Our aim is to 1. Encourage those students who live in rural areas and have the capability to do something but are lacking proper guidance . We want to help them to get on the right path through which they can achieve success in their lives. 2.Our second thought is about spending excessive money on the various institutes without knowing about what student wanted to do. They see that everyone is going there then we should also go, no, every institute is not right for everyone. Some students can study in large groups but some need a smaller group to catch on the teachings of the coach. So we want to help you in analyzing yourself before stepping under the roof of the coaching and spoiling the hard earned

Milestones and challenges during Pandemic

                      Interaction with students in a primary school at village, Jamalpur During the pandemic, time world has changed a lot and it affected millions of lives in a severe way. Lower middle-class people and daily wage workers' lives have become worse in India. Though the government did its best to help the people and provided them free food, medical services but still educational support was not even there. Due to the loss of the job the affected families were not able to financially support the education of their children, hence putting children's future in the dark. The most affected students were from rural areas and small cities where jobs were completely perished because of pandemics.  Hence we have run the following initiative during the pandemic  1. Connect to grow : During this time our non-profit organization started to connect to grow the program. Under this initiative, we started making collaboration with other non-profit organizations working in the sma